Patients' Rights Laws in Europe
Patient
rights
are a reflection of human rights. The human right movement has
gathered importance in the world since 1945, when, on 10 December 1948,
the Universal Declaration of
Human Rights was adopted. This was followed, on 4 November, 1950, by
the signature of the European
Convention
of Human Rights. The rights of the patients, as specific human
rights became recognized throughout the European region only in the past
two decades.
Especially important was the European
Consultation
on the Rights of Patients, held in Amsterdam on 28-30 March 1994
under the auspices of the WHO Regional Office for Europe (WHO-EURO), and
hosted by the Government of the Netherlands, which was attended by some 60
persons from 36 Member States. The purpose was to define principles and
strategies for promoting the rights of patients, within the context of the
health care reform process underway in most countries in Europe.
Access to patient files is secured by Article 18 of the Comment 34 to Article 19 (2) International
Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, Article 12 (b) (iv)General Comment 14 International
Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights.
Patients rights and their foundation in several European countries are
described here:
Contents
WHO Activities, Council of Europe and EU
| Organization |
Name with Link |
Translation |
| EU, 1979 |
Charter of the
Hospital patient: http://www.hope.be/07publi/publoth/Hospchart.htm. Continuation? |
|
| WHO, 1986 |
Ottawa
Charter for Health Promotion: http://www.euro.who.int/AboutWHO/Policy/20010827_2 |
Deutsch |
| WHO Europe, 1994 |
Declaration
on the promotion of patients' rights in Europe- Amsterdam March
1994: http://www1.umn.edu/humanrts/instree/patientrights.html |
|
| WHO Europe, 1996 |
Ljubljana Charter on Reforming
Health Care:
http://www.who.dk/AboutWHO/Policy/20010927_5
|
|
| Council of Europe, 1996 |
The 5th Conference of Health Ministers:
"Social challenge to health : equity and patients rights in
the context of health reforms":
http://www.social.coe.int/en/qoflife/publi/warsaw.htm |
|
| Council of Europe - ETS no. 164, 1997 |
Convention
for the Protection of Human Rights and Dignity of the Human
Being with regard to the Application of Biology and Medicine.
Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine |
Deutsch |
| WHO, 1997 |
Gothenburg
Workshop: Patients’ Rights in Europe as at June 1997: http://www.euro.who.int/document/e58605.pdf.
(Map of patterns)
|
|
| WHO Europe, 22-23
April 1999 |
Patients’
rights and citizens’ empowerment, Copenhagen, Denmark
22-23 April 1999. European
network for patients' rights: http://lists.essential.org/med-privacy/msg00294.html:
"Patients consistently report that their opinions are not adequately
considered and that their rights are often violated," said
Dr Mikko Vienonen, regional adviser at the WHO's
regional office for Europe. |
|
| Council of Europe, 2000 |
Recommendation Rec (2000) 5 on the
development of structures for citizen and patient participation in
the decision-making process affecting health care: http://www.social.coe.int/en/qoflife/recomm/R(00)5.htm
|
|
| EU, 2001 |
European Health Forum: http://europa.eu.int/comm/health/ph_overview/health_forum/open_forum_en.htm |
|
| EU, 2006 |
Health-EU
Portal: http://health.europa.eu/ |
|
Patients' Rights Laws
| Country |
Name with Link |
Translation |
| Finland, 1992 |
Lag
om patientens ställning och rättigheter (785/1992): http://www.mhbibl.aland.fi/patient/patientlag.html
|
Svensk |
| Netherlands, 1994 |
Dutch
Medical Treatment Act 1994: http://home.planet.nl/~privacy1/wgbo.htm |
|
Israel, 1996
|
Patient´s
Rights Act: http://waml.haifa.ac.il/index/reference/legislation/israel/israel1.htm |
|
| Lithuania,
1996 |
Law
on the Rights of Patients and Damage Done to Patients: http://www3.lrs.lt/c-bin/eng/preps2?Condition1=111935&Condition2= |
|
| Iceland, 1997 |
Lög um
réttindi sjúklinga: http://www.althingi.is/lagas/123a/1997074.html |
English |
| Latvia, 1997 |
Law of Medicine
(=The law on medical treatment): http://home.broadpark.no/~wkeim/files/Latvia_The_law_of_Medicine.htm |
|
| Hungary, 1997 |
Rights
and Obligations of Patients (According
to Act CLIV of 1997 on Health): http://www.eum.hu/english/CLIV/CLIV-main.html.
The Szószóló
Foundation supports patients rights. |
Hungarian |
| Greece, 1997 |
Law 2519/21-8-97 |
|
| Denmark, 1998 |
Lov
om patienters retsstilling, LOV nr 482 af 01/07/1998 |
English |
| Norway, 1999 |
Pasientrettighetsloven:
http://www.lovdata.no/all/hl-19990702-063.html.
Other Norwegian Health laws. |
Deutsch, English |
| Georgia, 2000 |
The Law of Georgia
on the Rights of patients |
|
| France, 2002 |
LOI n° 2002-303 du 4 mars 2002 relative aux droits des malades et
à la qualité du système de santé (1): http://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/WAspad/UnTexteDeJorf?numjo=mesx0100092l#
|
|
| Belgium, 2002 |
Act on Patients’ Rights, http://www.lachambre.be/documents/1642/15.pdf
(in Dutch or French). |
|
| Switzerland, 2003 |
Patientenrechtverordnung
1991, Patientenrechtsgesetz
ist in Vorbereitung: Hearing:
http://www.zh.ch/gd/aktuell/news/presseberichte/news_21_12_00_1a.htm |
|
| Russia |
Principles
of The Russian Federation Legislation No. 5487-I: On protection of
citizens' health of 22 July 1993 and amendments. (Patients
rights in several different laws) |
English and Russian |
| Estonia, 2002 |
Draft
of the Act on Patients' Rights PATSIENDISEADUS:
http://www.riigikogu.ee/ |
Estonian |
| Romania, 2003 |
Law of Patients’ Rights (law 46). Prof. Dr. Dan Tudor
Vuza: The Patient’s Family, between the Right to Know the Truth
and the Medical Secret |
|
| Cyprus, 2005 |
Law 1/2005: PATIENT
RIGHTS LAW |
Greek |
| Germany, 2013 |
Patient Rights
Law |
German |
Charters of the Rights of Patients
| Country |
Name with Link |
Translation |
| France 1974
and 1995 |
Charte
du Patient Hospitalisé: http://www.ch-erstein.fr/charte/chartepatient.html
|
|
| San Marino, 1989 |
|
|
| UK, (1991),
1997 |
The
Patient's Charter for England: http://www.pfc.org.uk/medical/pchrt-e1.htm |
|
| Czech Republic, 1992 |
|
|
| Spain, 1994 |
Charter of Rights and Duties of Patients |
|
| Ireland, 1995 |
Charter
of Rights for Hospital Patients |
|
| Malaysia, 1995 |
Patient's
Charter: http://prn.usm.my/edl/patient.html |
|
| South Africa, 1996 |
PATIENTS
RIGHTS CHARTER: http://www.hst.org.za/doh/rights_chart.htm |
|
| Portugal, 1997 |
Patients' Rights Charter: http://www.dgsaude.pt/carta.htm
|
|
| Honk Kong, 1999 |
Patients' Charter:
http://www.ha.org.hk/charter/pceng.htm |
|
| Germany, 1999 |
Charta
der Patientenrechte vom 9./10. Juni 1999: http://patientenstellen.de/patientencharta.html |
|
| Poland, 1999 |
Information
on patients rights by the Ministry of Health (Karta Praw Pacjenta).
Polish Patients
Association: Letter
to Commissioner for Human Rights. |
|
| Slovakia, 2000 |
Charter on the Patients Rights in the Slovak
Republic (draft): http://www.mdac.info/region/slovakia/index.html |
|
| Austria, 2001 |
Vereinbarung
zur Sicherstellung der Patientenrechte (Patientencharta): http://www.parlinkom.gv.at/pd/pm/XXI/I/texte/004/I00421_.html |
|
| Germany, 2001 |
Experts support patients' rights law: Sachverständigenrat
tritt für Patientenrechte-Gesetz ein. The German health system
is most expensive in EU, but only under average (World
Health Report 2000: Rank
25) in quality of services. Petition
der Bundesarbeitsgemeinschaft
der Notgemeinschaften Medizingeschädigter e.V. (PDF-format.) |
|
| Cyprus, 2001 |
Cyprus Patients Rights' Charter: http://www.activecitizenship.net/documenti/Cyprus
Charter Patients' Rights.doc |
|
| Germany, 2002 |
Patientenrechtscharta:
http://www.krankenkassen.de/gesundheit/arzt-patient/TODO-29/ |
|
| Europe, 2002 |
Active
Citizenship Network: European
Charter of Patients Rights http://www.activecitizenship.net/projects/europ_chart.htm |
|
| Italy |
Active Citizenship
Network: Italian
Charter of Patients Rights http://www.activecitizenship.net/health/italian_charter.pdf |
|
Six
years after the WHO Declaration on the Promotion of Patients’ Rights
in Europe (Amsterdam, 1994), more than eight countries (Denmark,
Finland, Georgia, Greece, Iceland, Israel, Lithuania, the Netherlands
and Norway) have enacted laws on the rights of patients; and four
countries (France, Ireland, Portugal and the United Kingdom) have used
Patients’ Charters as a tool to promote patients’ rights. (German
version). European Journal of Health Law 7: 1-3, 2000: Lars
Fallberg: Patients’
Rights
in Europe: Where do we stand and where do we go?
PatientNavigation
is intended to improve transparency in health care by providing support to
patients and their counsellors in finding their way through the tangled
web of the health care system. It is not designed as a pilot, guiding and
deciding, but as a compass that provides information but leaves the
decision with the person concerned.
Support the Rights of Patients by E-Mail to the
European Commission with a copy to the European Parliament.
Many countries in the EU have laws or charters securing the Rights of
Patients. But minimum standards are lacking. In order to give
all citizens in Europe a minimum of patients rights and to keep up with
the international development patients rights should be strengthened in EU
member states.
Support Patients Rights, by
the
following E-Mail to the European Commission (click here):
I
support the call to the European Commission for securing the rights
of patients.
I a guideline I suggest to use European Charter of
Patients Rights http://home.broadpark.no/~wkeim/files/european_charter.htm
and the "Recommendation Rec (2000) 5 of the Council of Europe on the
development of structures for citizen and patient participation in the
decision-making process affecting health care": http://www.social.coe.int/en/qoflife/recomm/R(00)5.htm
.
(You may change the text according to your needs).
Support the Rights of Patients by E-Mail to the
Federal Government in Germany
Many countries in the EU have laws securing the Rights of Patients.
Germany is one of the countries in the EU without such a law. In order to
keep up with the international development a law on patients' rights
should also be adopted in Germany.
Support a German Patients' Rights Law, by
the
following E-Mail to the German Government (click here):
I
support the call to the German Government for securing the rights of
patients by law.
I suggest to implement the European Charter of Patients Rights http://home.broadpark.no/~wkeim/files/european_charter.htm
and the "Recommendation Rec (2000) 5 of the Council of Europe on the
development of structures for citizen and patient participation in the
decision-making process affecting health care": http://www.social.coe.int/en/qoflife/recomm/R(00)5.htm
.
(You may change the text according to your needs).
Warning: I do not accept any
liability that the information on these pages is correct, accurate or up
to date!
Please feel free to link this site!
PS: Thanks to all, who gave me this information. Please do not hesitate
to mail
me if you have one of the "missing links".
Visitor No.
since 4. August 2001
[Critique
of Patients Rights in Germany]
[Patient laws in
Norway]
[Petitions] [Violations of Human Rights]
[Freedom of Information] [Back to Homepage]